315 Regret Ave
Lost Angeles, CA 90015
September 5
Dear Yesterday,
I hope this letter finds you well. As well as you can be after what I did to you.
I write you this letter while looking at a lovely photograph of us together at the fair from three summers ago. I don’t have to look too long at this picture to notice the beaming happiness on both our faces. September 26 (a day I will never forget) is the date marked on the back of the photo.
I was wearing a short black pleated skirt with those sneakers that you liked, and you had that classic plain white t-shirt and blue jeans look that I was crazy about.
In one hand I had that pink stuffed teddy bear you won for me after playing three brutal yet hilarious rounds of Whac-A-Mole, and with the other, I held on tightly to your waist. My head was cradled on your chest, and to this day I can still smell your alluring scent.
There was a tenderness in the way you looked at me, and my heart was so full due to the abundance of your pure love.
But that was years ago. A lot has changed since then. I like to go over those times in my mind because they give me a sense of comfort that at least there was a time when I made someone happy. A time when I made you happy.
Lately, though, the thought of you has been keeping me from sleeping. I keep recalling the look on your face as I was leaving. Almost every night I’ve been dreaming about you. Dreaming about us reconciling, but at the end of every dream, I still break your heart.
It is no secret that I have moved on, but have I truly? Have you? Do I ever cross your mind?
Each year when September comes, memories of you flood my mind. A part of me keeps holding on because I still care, I hope you still care.
Old friend, you were like my home. It hurts to think that now you are just someone I used to know.
I know that meeting up with me is not even an option for you. I don’t blame you, because the last time we spoke you told me you loved me, and all I said was nothing. I regret it because now I have so much to say to you.
I apologize for breaking your heart and I hope you are happy now wherever you are, with whomever you are with. I hope she treats you better and makes you throw your head back in laughter like you used to with me.
I don’t know what will happen after this letter reaches you, but just know that the words of our favorite song will always be true. At least to me:
“Whatever we deny or embrace, for worse or for better
We belong, we belong together.”
Sincerely,
Your first love